Home LifeStyle Fixing a Roof vs. Replacing a Roof – Choosing the Right Solution

Fixing a Roof vs. Replacing a Roof – Choosing the Right Solution

by Syed Qasim
0 comment

Last modified on June 5th, 2024 at 7:07 pm

Roof replacement involves swapping old shingles, felt paper, and moisture barriers with new ones. It may also require fixing the deck or any damage found after removing the previous roof. Repairing your roof generally only addresses isolated damage. If a storm or tree branch damages your roof, do you repair or replace it?

Here are eight things to consider before deciding.

•         Roof Age

Roofs’ lifespan depends on material and manufacturer, with many lasting 10-15 years and beyond. Repairing broken pieces may be sufficient for a few years, but ageing can wear out the roof. Replacing the roof is best, even if only a few damaged areas are present. Older roofs are harder to match shingles.

•         Extent of Damage 

Is the damage limited to a small area or one section of the roof? Did water penetrate the moisture barrier? Was the deck damaged or exposed? Did the damage cause a leak? Repairing may be less expensive than replacing the roof.

•         The kind of roof

The type of roof can influence whether to repair or replace it. Slate roofs can last over 100 years, while roof tiles can be replaced. Age also plays a role, as individual shingle replacement doesn’t prolong surrounding shingles.

•         Urgency

During a hurricane, repairing your roof is crucial to prevent future damage. Rebuilding after the storm may be more expensive than interim fixes, as water or wind damage may result.

•         Long-Term Plans

If you plan to stay in your house for a long time, replacing your roof may be justified. It will save costs and make your home more appealing to potential buyers.

•         Energy Efficiency

Roof materials and energy efficiency are continuously evolving, offering more options and potentially offset installation costs, depending on the age or type of roof.

•         Building Codes

Re-roofing is a cost-effective and quick solution for replacing old shingles without removing the existing roof. However, it’s not always recommended due to construction rules, extra weight, and potential violation of warranty guarantees. Despite the savings, it’s important to consider hidden expenses.

•         Budget

Understanding the cost of repairing vs. replacing a roof can help you decide. Repair is generally cheaper but may increase repair costs per square foot, material costs, and repair scope. The repair scope may also affect costs. Repairing by replacing missing or broken shingles is the cheapest option, but matching new and old shingles can be challenging.

Partially replacing the roof may leave the rest of the home with an old-looking roof. Full replacement is less expensive per square foot and allows for a thorough structural examination. Comprehensive roof replacements can use modern materials or upgrade to a better roof.

Bottom Line

It’s easy to focus on the replacement expense while choosing whether to repair or replace your roof. However, as you can see, there are a lot of variables that might influence your choice. If you’re unsure, a reputable service roofer like H Roofing Solutions might be a helpful source. They can comprehensively examine your roof and determine which of the previously listed issues pertain to you.

Leave a Comment

About Us

At Moral Story our aim is to provide the most inspirational stories around the world, featuring entrepreneurs, featuring failures and success stories, tech talks, gadgets and latest news on trending topics that matters to our readers.

Contact Us –

MoralStory – All Right Reserved. 2022

error: Content is protected !!